What would property tax relief from the Legislature mean for Texas renters?
In a two-bedroom South Austin apartment, Maddie Hastings goes through the familiar routine of giving a tour.
“Last year, I think I took about 350 leads and leased about 110 of those or so,” she told the Texas Standard.
As an apartment locator coming up on 3 1/2 years in the business, she knows exactly what people ask about. She makes note of the apartment’s large balcony, the in-unit washer and dryer, and the walk-in closet. Pacing through the kitchen, she points out stainless steel appliances, formica countertops and white cabinets with new hardware fixtures.
As a native Austinite who now spends her days comparing square footage, amenities and locations, Hastings describes a familiar routine to interactions with her clients: “Usually what happens is they’ll give me a budget, I’ll send them places within their budget, and then they realize what they want is going to cost more.”
In Texas, the median gross rent is $1,146 a month. For this apartment, a partially renovated 2-bed, 2-bath located in one of the country’s hottest real estate markets, that figure is $1,565.
“So, location, then size, then newness and niceness are typically the three things that for most people, they have to choose two out of three,” Hastings said.
Calculating cost of rent
When it comes to figuring out what factors into the cost of an apartment, there are a handful of well-known indicators among renters: size, location, age of the complex. For rental property owners, the calculation is a little different.
Things like insurance, repairs, mortgage payments and payroll expenses play a large role in operating rental properties – and according to research from the National Apartment Association, the biggest factor of all is property taxes, accounting for as much as 40% of all operating expenses.
» TELL US: What do you want to know about property taxes in Texas?
David Mintz, vice president of government affairs for the Texas Apartment Association, helps represent the interests of 10,000 rental property owners. His rough guideline for figuring out how much of a typical rent payment is earmarked for taxes is that it can be twenty cents on the dollar or more going toward the property tax bill.
All this means that when property taxes rise, landlords will often raise rents in response.
Of course, property owners always have the option of selling their property should taxes (or any other expense) become too burdensome, but as Mintz points out, “the difficulty is when somebody else comes in to buy that property, if they’re going to maintain it as a rental property, they still have the same pressures of those operating costs that get translated to rent.”
A sign of relief
The Texas Legislature is back in session, and the biggest item on lawmakers’ agenda at the moment is figuring out what to do with a $32 billion budget surplus – and the issue with broadest support is property tax relief. Initial budget proposals from both the Texas House and Senate have set aside $15 billion to ease property tax bills.
“Property taxes are one of the top issues for our association this session, and we’re really pleased to see that the Legislature is looking at using a substantial part of the surplus to help provide some property tax relief,” Mintz said.
» MORE: Could taxed marijuana sales lower Texans’ property taxes?
With more than 60% of Texans owning the residences they live in, robust property tax relief is an understandably popular proposal. For renters, though, the benefit is not as straightforward.
Emily Eby French, a voting rights attorney who rents in Austin, said that allocating so much money for property tax relief is a missed opportunity: “There are just so many issues in Texas where money would fix the problem,” she said.
Eby French extends a lot of sympathy to any Texan struggling to cover the property tax bill, whether it be low-income homeowners, those on fixed incomes or even smaller-scale landlords – she’s even got a close personal friend who rents out property on the side. “We do bust his chops a lot in the group chat,” she joked.
The state’s surplus, she insists, should be more narrowly focused on things like raising teacher pay, increasing funding in Texas’ foster care system, and expanding social programs.
“I do understand that if you need a passive income and you already were able to buy a place, that can be something I sympathize with – and still would rather have teacher pay increases than cut my landlord friend a check, and I think he would understand,” she said.
A potential upside for renters
If renters are going to see the benefits of property tax relief, it’ll have to be through their property owners. Mintz points out that generous property tax relief could help landlords hold off on further rent increases.
“That’s probably a good way to think about it,” he said. “If there is property tax relief, more likely than not, that relief is going to help mitigate the pressure to increase rents more.”
If you found the reporting above valuable, please consider making a donation to support it here. Your gift helps pay for everything you find on texasstandard.org and KUT.org. Thanks for donating today.