Border Community Remembers A Father And Daughter Who Drowned Crossing The Rio Grande

Originally published on September 5, 2019 8:43 am

Residents in the Rio Grande Valley gathered at vigils in McAllen and Brownsville, Texas, on Sunday evening to remember the lives of Óscar Alberto Martínez Ramírez and his 23-month-old daughter, Angie Valeria.

The Salvadoran father and daughter drowned as they tried to cross the river between Matamoros and Brownsville on June 23. Valeria's mother, Tania Vanessa Ávalos, watched as her family was swept away.

Julia Le Duc, a journalist working for La Jornada, took a photo that showed Ramírez and his daughter facedown by the riverbank. The child was tucked into her father's shirt, her arm still around his neck. The image went viral and shed light on restrictive U.S. government immigration policies like "metering" that have pushed some desperate migrants to risk crossing the river between ports of entry.

The vigil at Brownsville's Hope Park was only about a mile from where the bodies were found.

Photos of the Salvadoran family rested on a table. Some people held signs and others held candles that were lit during the vigil.

Joyce Hamilton, a member of the group Angry Tias and Abuelas, spoke to the crowd. "On the way here tonight," she said, "all I could think is that there's no way I could talk tonight because this whole past week or so has been just so crushing."

Organizations like Angry Tias and Abuelas regularly help migrants in Mexico and in the U.S. They worked with other groups to organize the vigils.

Gabriela Zavala, the executive director of a respite center at a local church, took a turn speaking at the vigil.

"We only know a few things about them," she said, "but we do know this. We know that they, like many immigrants before them and many immigrants after them, made the ultimate sacrifice to leave their countries behind to brave a dangerous trek in search of safety and a better life."

Zavala says their deaths were the result of a failed immigration system, and she called on the community to demand from their elected officials better representation for the needs of all at the border.

"Demand that they end family separation and detention, and that they hold our leaders accountable for terrible policymaking," said Zavala. "Policies like metering that keeps our asylum-seekers waiting in Mexico, despite the knowledge that they undergo very bad treatment and that the conditions are terrible."

At a migrant camp in Matamoros, just across the river from Brownsville, a Honduran woman named Xiomara said she remembered meeting Ramírez and his daughter Valeria only hours before their deaths. She said she also met the toddler's mother.

Xiomara said she wanted to use only her first name because she feared speaking out might hurt her family's asylum claim.

Her family is on a list managed by Mexican officials, who coordinate with U.S. Customs and Border Protection. Only a few migrants, if any, are allowed into the U.S. during any given week — a process referred to as metering. According to a report from the Office of the Inspector General, it likely persuades migrants to cross the river between ports of entry rather than endure the delay.

"They came here Saturday afternoon and asked me for information about the infamous list," explained Xiomara, "and I told them they needed to return Monday morning. ... They told me they were surprised when I told them I've been here for more than two months."

Xiomara said the family asked her if she had ever thought about crossing the river. She told them no. She said Ramírez then told her they would return on Monday so that they could be added to the list.

The next day, two Peruvians who waited in line for more than three weeks informed her that Ramírez and Valeria had drowned.

"They told me they saw a woman crying when her child was drowning. They got here scared and told me a man and little girl drowned," Xiomara said. "I never thought it would be Óscar or the little girl."

The Peruvian man, who did not want his name used because he feared speaking out might hurt his asylum claim, said he saw a group of people by the river. When he moved closer, he recognized Ávalos, Ramírez's wife.

"She was crying uncontrollably, saying they had come to the U.S. for help," the Peruvian man said.

The bodies were found a day after they drowned, last Monday.

Xiomara said Valeria's smile was luminous and she thought Valeria's parents were a beautiful couple. Ramírez was 25, and Ávalos is 21.

She shared her memories from her camp near the international bridge. As she spoke, children chased each other, a man slept on a thin foam mattress and others chatted and endured the summer heat.

Xiomara and her family are now No. 3 on the metering list, but she estimated they would be in Mexico for at least another two weeks before they're finally allowed into the U.S. to be processed at a facility on the other side of the border. She said it hasn't been easy for her family because they have to spend their days under the hot sun, and they don't have water, showers or bathrooms.

She says that once she makes it across to the U.S., and if her asylum claim is successful, she'll head to the East Coast, where she has family. She added that she will seek medical treatment for her daughter who has a tumor and experiences seizures.

Another woman at the camp sat under the roof of a building for shade. The woman came from Cuba with her husband and daughter. She said she is five months pregnant and has been waiting to be allowed into the U.S. for about 17 days. She said she didn't realize she'd have to wait so long, admitting she has considered crossing the river.

"I was thinking about it before this incident occurred," she said — referring to the drownings. "I haven't checked if everything is OK with my baby. Having a 1 1/2-year-old kid also makes me very anxious because I don't see the line moving."

At Sunday's vigil, Zavala's rallying cry resounded among those in the crowd.

"And something else that helps me get through this, this tragedy that the deaths of Óscar and Valeria will not go in vain," said Zavala.

Copyright 2019 Texas Public Radio. To see more, visit Texas Public Radio.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

For many people, a single image has come to symbolize the struggles of migrants heading for the United States border - the image of two bodies face down in the Rio Grande, a Salvadoran father and his daughter. Residents in Texas's Rio Grande Valley held vigils last night to remember the lives of Oscar Alberto Martinez Ramirez and his 23-month-old daughter Angie Valeria. Texas Public Radio's Reynaldo Leanos Jr. was at one of the vigils in Brownsville.

REYNALDO LEANOS JR, BYLINE: People from across the Rio Grande Valley begin arriving at Hope Park to honor the lives of Oscar and Valeria. It's about a mile from where their bodies were found. Photos of the family rest on a table. People hold signs and candles.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

JOYCE HAMILTON: Hi, everyone. I'm Joyce, and I'm with Angry Tias and Abuelas. On the way here tonight, all I could think was, there's no way I can talk tonight because this whole past week has just been so crushing.

LEANOS: Organizations like Joyce's, made up of aunts and grandmothers, help migrants in Mexico and in the U.S. by providing food, water, clothes and assistance. They and others helped put together the vigil. Gabriela Zavala, the executive director of a respite center at a local church, addresses a crowd about the father and daughter whose deaths they are gathered to remember.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

GABRIELA ZAVALA: We only know a few things about them, but we do know this - we know that they, like many immigrants before them and many immigrants after them, made the ultimate sacrifice to leave their countries behind and brave a dangerous trek in search of safety, security and a better life.

LEANOS: Zavala says their deaths were the result of a failed immigration system and called on the community to demand for their elected officials better representation for the needs of all at the border.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ZAVALA: Demand that they help us end family separation and detention, and that they hold our leaders accountable for terrible policymaking, policies like metering, that keeps our asylum-seekers waiting in Mexico, despite the knowledge that they undergo very bad treatment, and that the conditions are terrible.

LEANOS: Across from Brownsville in Matamoros, a Honduran woman named Xiomara is waiting with her family in a makeshift camping area. Her family have been put on a list managed by Mexican immigration officials who coordinate with U.S. Customs and Border Protection. Only a few, if any, are allowed into the U.S. every week for processing, a practice known as metering. She asked to go by her first name because she fears speaking out will hurt her claim for asylum.

XIOMARA: (Speaking Spanish).

LEANOS: Xiomara says they came here and asked her for information about the infamous list. She says she met Oscar, his wife Tania Vanessa Avalos and their daughter Valeria hours before the deaths. She says they were surprised when she told them she'd been waiting for more than two months.

Xiomara says Oscar asked her if she had ever thought about crossing the river, but she told him no. He then told her they would come back on Monday so they could try to be added to the list. The next day she heard about the death of the father and daughter from two Peruvians who had also been waiting to claim asylum.

XIOMARA: (Speaking Spanish).

LEANOS: Xiomara says she never thought it would be Oscar and Valeria. Their bodies were found on Monday. She says they were a beautiful family. Xiomara and her family are now No. 3 on the list, but she thinks she'll be in Mexico for at least another two weeks until she's finally allowed into the U.S. into a processing facility. At the vigil, Zavala's rallying cry resounds among those in the crowd.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ZAVALA: And something else that helps me get through this tragedy is that the deaths of Oscar and Valeria will not go in vain.

LEANOS: For NPR News, I'm Reynaldo Leanos Jr. in Brownsville, Texas.

(SOUNDBITE OF OLAFUR ARNALDS' "MOMENTARY") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.